New Theory of 3 Timelines

Published November 18, 2016 · Updated July 6, 2022

So I got hooked up to your podcast as well, you are doing a great job. Here is my humble contribution.

I must admit that I’m quite surprised by the fact that it seems like everyone missed one huge hint in the series, that might serve as a proof to a new theory of 3 timelines, one that I have not heard of so far.

In Maeve’s saloon, there is a bartender. There are two different hosts who acts as the bartender, one with a black mustache (played by Bradford Tatum) and one with a white mustache (played by Bradley Fisher). The black one appears in episode 1 in the first scene in which Teddy comes to town, the one where the man in black kidnaps Kissy, and the one where Hector and his bandits raid to the city. The white one appears in the rest of Maeve’s episodes. When you check it carefully you realize that those scenes in episode 1 are the only ones that connect Maeve to the man in black story lines and Ford’s code update story lines (and time lines for that matter). Other than that, there is no reason to think Maeve’s story line happens at the same time as any other story we see, which might mean a third timeline.

One more thing worth noting. The black mustache host is the one used as Dolores new(?) father, which gives a reason to think that Maeve’s story takes place after Peter Abernathy is decommissioned. On the other hand, he is shown again in episode 3 where Dolores get’s home alone (after Teddy left her and rode with the sheriff in order to chase Wyatt), finds her dad dead and has a flashback. It’s not clear which one is the “real” father and which is the memory, but either way it means this story happened at the same time or after the time she got the new father.

Wonder what are your thoughts

Moshe (it’s like Moses, just in Hebrew)

Subscribe Now