MIB & Dolores In the Park

Published April 24, 2020 · Updated July 6, 2022

Hey guys,

Quick one this week, which I know would end up on next week’s Telegraph at this point but I hope you consider it anyway:

WHY does everyone (including Ashley on the Decoherence Deep Dive) reference “what William did to Dolores” in the park as if it’s a foregone conclusion that he raped and murdered her over and over again? I don’t want to put words in Ashley’s mouth specifically, but it seems every podcaster, tv critic, and fan assumes whatever went on behind those barn doors was horrific and repeated. Was it? I know dragging a lady by the hair isn’t exactly polite, but doesn’t it seem suspect, or at least deliberate, that we’ve never been given a full, unedited view of what would go on between Dolores and older William behind the barn doors?

I know this seems like a Season 1 question, but since it keeps coming up in the pod (and in my brain) I thought it might be worth taking the opportunity to ask for your thoughts. Keep up the excellent work, people. You guys are the best.

– Karl

Subscribe Now